Morals and Ethics

Questions about how we live together from religious and atheist perspectives.

August 17, 2004
A Hope for America

It's time for us to stop hating saints just because most of us haven't yet found the nerve to be one.

Posted by Joel at 11:00 PM | Read More
August 15, 2004
Swift Kick and Punt Return

Because blogging has become popular and has drawn off a small sliver of the public who might otherwise mindlessly read the country's major newspapers or watch its television media, we are now targetted by the same people who have been maneuvering big media to toe the Republican line.

Posted by Joel at 10:33 PM | Read More
August 06, 2004
A Test for Evil: Homosexuality

I'd like to suggest a test for evil and use homosexuality as the subject. The test is simple: an act can be called evil if it causes harm.

Posted by Joel at 01:36 PM | Read More
August 05, 2004
Intelligence, Sanity, Good, and Evil

An unchecked faith in our intelligence -- just like an unchecked faith in anything -- may be our own worst enemy. It is in the name of intelligence, I feel, that we make some of our greatest blunders.

Posted by Joel at 11:34 PM | Read More
August 04, 2004
Pot-Bellied Buddhism

The pot-bellied Buddha serves as the Bible does for Fundamentalists when they justify war, violence, and consumerism: to mystify and hide the nonspiritual, sense-bound nature of the hedonist lifestyle.

Posted by Joel at 07:37 PM | Read More
July 31, 2004
Bots and Guns

While editing the same massive script that I have been editing for the last two weeks, I came across the phrase "I do not like guns". ALICE, who professes to be a libertarian, asks "What about the Second Amendment?

Posted by Joel at 10:35 PM | Read More
July 18, 2004
Naked Quakers

If it had just been a group of teenagers," said Shari, "they probably would have overlooked it.

Posted by Joel at 01:20 PM | Read More
June 16, 2004
The "For the Sake of Argument" Argument

Straussian discourse must continually engage us in argument about things already proved so that the interests of the chosen elite will not be threatened.

Posted by Joel at 01:14 PM | Read More
May 25, 2004
Cowbird Morals

Stealth is not nearly as important as brazen insertion.

Posted by Joel at 04:54 PM | Read More
May 19, 2004
Catholics and the Hanging Gut

Why not just feel good about the way we look?

Posted by Joel at 01:40 PM | Read More
Catholic Suttee

When martyrdom is chosen because of social pressure and not because of personal devotion, it becomes murder.

Posted by Joel at 01:18 AM | Read More
May 18, 2004
Stephen Riddle Responds

It is increasingly hard for American Catholics on the Left.

Posted by Joel at 05:46 PM | Read More
May 14, 2004
Ecclesia reformada

I excommunicated the Catholic Church from giving me sacraments.

Posted by Joel at 11:33 PM | Read More
May 08, 2004
Fundamentalism is Overpermissive about Fat

"Oh, I eat very little," you hear them say. Then you see them, with their plates piled high at a smorgabord and you know that most of them are liars.

Posted by Joel at 02:52 PM | Read More
April 27, 2004
If Lucifer had a Hammer

Since when is Kevin one to complain about religious tolerance when he doesn't even acknowledge that leftist Catholics and others exist?

Posted by Joel at 08:31 PM | Read More
Suspend the Ump

I can see no reason for calling for the removal of the hijab from this woman's head, not for safety, not to make it easy to discern which team the woman played for.

Posted by Joel at 08:56 AM | Read More
April 24, 2004
More on Religious Tolerance

When statements about tolerance are couched in "We won't be able to win this one without them" you send the message that what matters most is the winning of the election, not the principles.

Posted by Joel at 10:27 PM | Read More
Religious Tolerance

For all their talk about tolerance, what are Patrick and Kevin doing to support the Christian Left?

Posted by Joel at 10:21 AM | Read More
April 19, 2004
The Inconvenience Posed by Sufis

This Catholic woman insisted that Sufism was part of a long established Islamic plot to create fellow travelers.

Posted by Joel at 01:50 AM | Read More
April 01, 2004
Goldilocks Robbed the Three Bears

Baby Bear smashes what is left of his chair over Goldilock's head.

Posted by Joel at 02:42 PM | Read More
March 27, 2004
The Poor and Rich

The poor are materialistic but the wealthy want power, not just to own objects but to own people, too.

Posted by Joel at 02:41 PM | Read More
March 23, 2004
Amending Arendt: Camp X-Ray Reveals Banal Evil

What "allegedly" happened in Camp X-Ray wasn't torture: it was sexual harassment, not unlike what Catherine McKinnon and others saw happening to women in the American workplace.

Posted by Joel at 10:24 PM | Read More
March 14, 2004
Scourges by God?

The message out of the Bible and out of Science is that these things are just diseases.

Posted by Joel at 08:54 PM | Read More
March 13, 2004
From a Notebook

I'm with Wittgenstein on this: scientific philosophy looks at things, describes them.

Posted by Joel at 04:04 PM | Read More
March 09, 2004
Martyrdom 6: Catholic Martyrs, Attis, Pious Frauds, and BDSM

It was not for beauty that the early church fathers banned the damaged from celebrating the Mass; the prelates were more concerned about the barbarous lengths to which some interpreted scripture and pagan rites in which initiates altered themselves.

Posted by Joel at 10:27 PM | Read More
March 08, 2004
Pseudonyms

I reject this thinking as unethical and as a capitulation.

Posted by Joel at 08:27 PM | Read More
March 05, 2004
Martydom 5: Vukovar, Guernica, and Hiroshima

I refused to take the side of any government, any army in a war.

Posted by Joel at 10:48 PM | Read More
March 03, 2004
Hannah Arendt on Eichmann

What mattered in the case of Eichmann is that he wanted to please his superiors.

Posted by Joel at 10:56 PM | Read More
March 02, 2004
Martyrdom 4: The Soot in the Fields

To thwart them, we must tell the whole truth. Sixteen million people died in the Holocaust: Jews, Gypsies, Slavs, homosexuals, and "defectives".

Posted by Joel at 11:20 PM | Read More
March 01, 2004
Martyrdom 3: Esprit de Corps

Generals such as Patton like to think that they are the high priests of vast congregations called "armies", but from what I have heard and read from grunts the spiritual community is more akin to that of Quakers than to the Vatican or Shinto.

Posted by Joel at 09:15 PM | Read More
February 29, 2004
Martyrdom 2: Pyramids, Tophets, and a Ram in a Thicket

The man or woman who lies down upon the altar is called a victim, from the Latin victima meaning an animal used for sacrifice. The word comes from an Indo-European root "weik" signifying that which is magic and holy.

Posted by Joel at 07:35 PM | Read More
February 28, 2004
Passion and The Passion in Lake Forest

Sitting in a restaurant talking about how the movie moved us is not putting ourselves in the position of Jesus, who suffered the tortures, carried the cross, and expired with his hands and feet pinned to its wood while slowly suffocating.

Posted by Joel at 10:00 PM | Read More
Martyrdom 1: The Martyrs of York and Edith Stein

Which were the martyrs of York? The ones who killed themselves or the ones who were massacred by the crowd?

Posted by Joel at 02:46 PM | Read More
February 24, 2004
Shooting P(h)easants

Tonight in the philosophy reading group that I attend, I advanced the idea (based on a reading of Iris Murdoch) that good was based on being aware of your place in the Universe and evil was a denial of that place.

Posted by Joel at 09:30 PM | Read More
February 19, 2004
The Golden Rule and Getting Laid

"Hey, I like people coming up to me and saying 'Do you want to have sex with me?' So it's OK for me to ask, right?"

Posted by Joel at 01:52 PM | Read More
February 09, 2004
Hijacked for God?

Passengers dialed relatives, perhaps in fear that they'd booked a ticket on a Christian Identity suicide mission.

Posted by Joel at 03:41 PM | Read More
January 06, 2004
Adolf, Dubya, and Me

if notified of such a funeral in Orange County, California and physically capable of doing so, I will attend, wearing only my dark suit and making no political comment at the scene.

Posted by Joel at 11:32 AM | Read More
December 03, 2003
Three Rights

Three fundamental human rights occur to me after the recent discussion here about domestic violence.

Posted by Joel at 03:10 PM | Read More
December 02, 2003
Honor, Shame, Friends, and Therapy

I can do without the good old days when we kept matters of incest and rape to ourselves. Rofayda Qaoud deserved shelter and understanding. If she couldn't find it within her family and her circle of friends, why couldn't she go outside of that box for it?

Posted by Joel at 03:19 PM | Read More
Prejudiced against the Rich?

"The rich are not like you and me" F. Scott Fitzgerald says in The Great Gatsby.

Posted by Joel at 09:02 AM | Read More
December 01, 2003
Culture of Victimization

If the charity of the wealthy is to be taken seriously, there can be no returns on it.

Posted by Joel at 10:53 PM | Read More
November 28, 2003
Money 2

Money is a useful tool. So is a hammer.

Posted by Joel at 05:46 PM | Read More
November 11, 2003
Church Sign

Make your own by clicking on the image!

Posted by Joel at 02:27 PM | Read More
November 01, 2003
Intelligent Design Network, Inc. Bears False Witness

I argue that, on the contrary, by promoting this ends justify the means attempt to seize hold of the American mind, Intelligent Design Network, Inc. is setting a hideous moral example for the youth they purport to "protect".

Posted by Joel at 08:21 PM | Read More
October 24, 2003
If Christ Drove....

The license plate holder read "Mission Viejo: DIABLOS".

Posted by Joel at 10:53 PM | Read More
October 19, 2003
Seen at a Bookstore

The newest book by GE chairman Jack Welch says that he is "speaks from the gut".

Posted by Joel at 08:14 PM | Read More
October 17, 2003
Hedonism and Greed

It's on the left that you will find peacemakers, people persecuted for righteousness sake, the poor, etc.

Posted by Joel at 10:50 AM | Read More
October 03, 2003
The Issue of Trust

Arnold's candidacy is thus undermining my faith in other people.

Posted by Joel at 01:14 AM | Read More
October 01, 2003
The Law and Morality

The logic is telling: if the law changes to allow a person to become legitimized, then that person is no longer illegal and therefore no longer morally suspect. The question which must follow is this: if the only thing that has changed is the status of the person under the law and not the behavior, why declare them morally reprehensible in the first place?

Posted by Joel at 01:31 AM | Read More
The Ten Commandments

It is unhealthy for any free society or any free religion to allow healthy and vigorous debate to be shut down by the whims of a majority -- no matter how slender or how broad. It kills the community and kills the soul.

Posted by Joel at 12:25 AM | Read More
September 30, 2003
An Alabama Recall

Riley, who is a devout Christian and a man of conscience, read a theological paper that discussed the Christian's obligation to the poor. His tax reform would have shifted the tax burden off the backs of the working poor and onto the backs of the wealthy.

Posted by Joel at 12:31 AM | Read More
September 26, 2003
The Gutless Agnostic Pacifist Speaks Up

Every Christian blog needs it's token agnostic!

Posted by Joel at 05:07 PM | Read More
September 22, 2003
Buddhism and War

During the heyday of Buddhism on the Indian subcontinent, emperors such as Harsha of Kanauj and Dharmapala of Binhar and Bengal waged wars of expansion quite avidly, despite their faith.

Posted by Joel at 03:58 PM | Read More
September 18, 2003
Mexican Gardeners and Middle Class Copouts

we claim that we want this end to illegal immigration. So why don't we seek lifestyles that are less dependant on lawns and nonnative shrubs?

Posted by Joel at 10:22 PM | Read More
September 14, 2003
Sin
Note: This is part of a series based on exercises from A Writer's Book of Days. It's something of a...
Posted by Joel at 11:30 PM | Read More
September 12, 2003
Another Perversion of Founding Thoughts

It seems to me that the CC has hit on a way to bring moneychangers into the virtual temple.

Posted by Joel at 05:53 PM | Read More
September 06, 2003
Polygamy: A Descendant Thinks On It

If polygamy were legal, would I do it?

Posted by Joel at 08:35 PM | Read More
September 04, 2003
Relativism is Not a Morality

Those who insist that cultural relativism demands that we declare two cultures to be "equally wrong" on any given issue are -- dare I say it? -- wrong.

Posted by Joel at 09:15 PM | Read More
August 18, 2003
The Great Ape Molester

If Arnold becomes governor, expect the State of California to be wrapped up in sexual harassment lawsuits due to his behavior for years to come.

Posted by Joel at 05:47 PM | Read More
August 16, 2003
Why Questions Do Not Get Asked

It's too upsetting, for these, to think that we might be flawed and promoting ideals that are evil.

Posted by Joel at 12:39 AM | Read More
August 15, 2003
Arnold's Charity 2

So, Arnold, where's the renunciation of your films? Where are your demands to suppress your oeuvre of violence? Why did you make a Terminator 3 if you are a "peace-loving guy"?

Posted by Joel at 10:02 PM | Read More
August 14, 2003
Arnold's Charity

What impresses me is Arnold's dedication to promoting his own name as an actor and as a gubenatorial candidate.

Posted by Joel at 09:15 PM | Read More
August 02, 2003
The Ambiguity of Our Time

Our troops are doing monstrous things in Iraq and they're being undercompensated for it.

Posted by Joel at 08:17 PM | Read More
July 24, 2003
Hunting Confirmed?

Living in this world of violence pornography, surrounded by men who love it, can we really say that she is making a fully informed choice?

Posted by Joel at 02:44 PM | Read More
Hunting Women

Civil libertarian that I am, allowing as I do the expression of many bizarre practices as long as they do no harm to those involved, I must scream that willing or not, this harms not only the woman who runs but all women.

Posted by Joel at 12:24 AM | Read More
July 01, 2003
Special Rights

I'd like to turn the insinuation on its head: heterosexuals who oppose homosexual marriage are demanding special rights on the basis of their sexuality.

Posted by Joel at 11:31 PM | Read More
June 23, 2003
Jesus Opposed Prayer in School

You cannot serve two masters, Jesus warned us, but the prayer in school advocates pretend that God and Caesar are the same, which is clearly counter-Christian.


Posted by Joel at 01:32 AM | Read More
June 20, 2003
The Other Jesus

The more I see Fundamentalists running around attacking others, the more I believe that there must be a second Jesus Christ, other than the one who delivered the Beatitudes.

Posted by Joel at 10:15 PM | Read More
May 01, 2003
On Open Mindedness: A Pacifist Manifesto

To my pacifist friends: Keep the faith!

Posted by Joel at 05:58 PM | Read More
April 29, 2003
Baby Killers?

I still maintain that I while I do not support "our boys" as they ransack Iraq, I also will not fling nasty epithets at them when they return home.

Posted by Joel at 09:28 PM | Read More
April 17, 2003
Sermon on the March:
Beatitudes for the American "Christian"

For a contrary view on the meaning of Christianity, read Matthew 5: 3-11.

Posted by Joel at 08:00 PM | Read More
April 05, 2003
George W. Bush: Servant of Satan or Servant of God?

"I'm glad we have a Christian president," said "big_jizo" and I said "We don't."

Posted by Joel at 11:45 PM | Read More
March 31, 2003
Blackhawk Clowns

De Genova passes himself off as an ally in the struggle against the Bush Blitzkrieg of the checks against the rampages of the presidency and the sell-out GOPher Congress, but he's a friend I'd rather not have.

Posted by Joel at 09:00 PM | Read More
March 27, 2003
Prayer Resolution

Sometimes I think I left Christianity and became a agnostic so that I could better live the words of Christ.

Posted by Joel at 04:34 AM | Read More
March 26, 2003
My Father and the Cruise Missile

The night the cruise missiles rained on Bagdhad in 1991, I lay in my bed. I was desperate; I was in a distinct, determined minority because of my opposition, and I was not at all quiet: I was screaming.

Posted by Joel at 08:07 PM | Read More
March 24, 2003
Support our Troops? -- The Question is HOW?

Photos of "our boys" show them to be relatively fat and happy compared to these children. They will be in the crucible for a matter of weeks. The children of Iraq were born to this horror and they've been in it for years.

Posted by Joel at 03:26 PM | Read More
March 20, 2003
Our "Boys" are Men Who Made Choices

If anyone can devise a program whereby an Iraqi soldier gets one care package for each one I send to an Allied soldier, I will take part.

Posted by Joel at 09:02 PM | Read More
December 28, 2002
St. Antony's Sister

It makes a sweet story if you don't think it through.

Posted by Joel at 08:33 PM | Read More
December 21, 2002
A Blank Pillar

Charity isn't another form of glory or advertising.

Posted by Joel at 07:18 PM | Read More
December 18, 2002
The Gura and Others, Revisited

I know I sound extremely selfish right now. So does a starving woman when the subject of food comes up.

Posted by Joel at 07:46 PM | Read More
The Gura

I never caught on until later that I was being sized up for two things: the size of my discretionary income and my sexual attractiveness.

Posted by Joel at 02:52 AM | Read More
November 26, 2002
Homosexuality and The Divine Comedy

I support same sex marriage and discourage homosexual promiscuity in the same spirit that I discourage heterosexual promiscuity.

Posted by Joel at 08:48 PM | Read More
August 06, 2002
Crazy Tracy vs. the Vatican

I can't for the life of me see why the Vatican doesn't think that women are fit to preach the Gospel.

Posted by Joel at 10:48 PM | Read More